Yes. In California, you can still recover compensation after a car crash even if you were partly at fault. California follows “pure” comparative negligence, so your damages are reduced by your percentage of fault, but they are not wiped out, even if you were 50% or more responsible. The same rule applies when a family brings a wrongful death claim and the insurance company argues their loved one shared the blame.
Insurance adjusters know that many injured people assume they have no case once someone suggests they did something wrong. That assumption can cost seriously injured people and grieving families a great deal of money. Here is how shared fault actually works under California law, how it is proven, and what you can do to protect your claim.
What Is Comparative Negligence in California?
Comparative negligence (also called comparative fault) is the rule that divides responsibility for a crash among everyone whose carelessness helped cause it. Each person’s share of responsibility is expressed as a percentage, and the injured person’s compensation is reduced by their own percentage.
California adopted this rule in the California Supreme Court’s landmark decision Li v. Yellow Cab Co. (1975) 13 Cal.3d 804, a case that arose from a crash at Alvarado and Third Streets in Los Angeles. The Court replaced the old “all-or-nothing” contributory negligence rule, which barred any recovery if the injured person was even slightly at fault, with a system that “assesses liability in direct proportion to fault.”
The rule also traces back to California Civil Code section 1714(a), which makes everyone responsible for injuries caused by their lack of ordinary care.
Can I Recover Damages If I Was More Than 50% at Fault?
Yes. In Li, the Court chose the “pure” form of comparative negligence, under which damages are apportioned “in spite of the fact that the plaintiff is equally at fault as or more at fault than the defendant.” Many other states cut off recovery once the injured person reaches 50% or 51% fault. California does not.
Here is a simple example of how the math works:
- A jury finds your total damages are $1,000,000.
- The jury finds the other driver 80% at fault and you 20% at fault.
- Your recovery is reduced by 20%, to $800,000.
Even if the percentages were reversed, you could still recover 20% of your damages. In a catastrophic injury case with very high medical costs and lost earnings, that can still be significant. (These figures are only an illustration, not a prediction of what any case is worth.)
How Is Fault Decided in a California Injury Case?
In a lawsuit, the defendant has the burden of proving your share of fault. Under California’s jury instruction on the plaintiff’s comparative fault, CACI No. 405, the defense must prove both that you were negligent and that your negligence was a substantial factor in causing your harm. If it does, the jury assigns a percentage and the judge calculates the reduction.
That second requirement matters. Doing something wrong is not enough; the defense must show your conduct actually contributed to your injuries. When there are several defendants, or others who share blame, the jury divides responsibility among all of them.
Most claims settle before trial, so in practice fault is negotiated between your lawyer and the insurance company. Adjusters often assign a percentage of fault early, sometimes based on little more than a short police report or a recorded statement, and then use it to discount their offer.
Does the Police Report Decide Who Was at Fault?
No. A traffic collision report is an important piece of evidence, and it can influence an insurance company’s view of the claim, but the officer’s opinion is not the final word on civil liability. Officers often arrive after the crash, may not speak to every witness, and may not have access to video, vehicle data, or reconstruction analysis.
We have seen this firsthand. In one matter, our client was placed at fault in the police report and still obtained a policy limits settlement. If you need a copy of the report, our guide explains how to get a California collision report after a fatal crash.
What Arguments Do Insurance Companies Use to Blame the Injured Person?
Common shared-fault arguments in California crash cases include:
- Speeding or following too closely, even when the other driver ran a light or made an unsafe left turn.
- Pedestrian conduct, such as crossing outside a crosswalk. California’s Vehicle Code section 21950 requires drivers to yield to pedestrians in marked and unmarked crosswalks and says pedestrians still must use due care. Since 2023, Vehicle Code section 21955 limits when officers may stop pedestrians for crossing mid-block, but it expressly keeps both the pedestrian’s duty of care and the driver’s duty of care for pedestrians in the roadway.
- Motorcyclist lane position or speed, often raised regardless of what the other driver did.
- Not wearing a seatbelt or helmet. The defense typically must connect this to the injuries, not just point it out.
- Distraction, such as claims that the injured person was on a phone, which can often be tested with records.
- Statements made at the scene or to an adjuster, like “I didn’t see them” or “I’m sorry,” which may be taken out of context.
Does Shared Fault Apply in California Wrongful Death Cases?
Yes. In a wrongful death case, the family generally “stands in the shoes” of the person who died, and the defense can argue that the decedent’s own negligence contributed to the crash. If the jury agrees, the family’s recovery is reduced by that percentage. As the California Supreme Court’s opinions in Horwich v. Superior Court (1999) 21 Cal.4th 272 discuss, the decedent’s comparative negligence can be asserted against the heirs.
Shared-fault arguments are especially common in fatal crashes because the person who died cannot tell their side. That is why early investigation, preserving video, and getting independent reconstruction can be so important. Our guides on how compensation is calculated in a California wrongful death case and what happens when a passenger dies and the driver was a friend or relative cover related questions.
What If More Than One Party Was at Fault?
Many serious crashes involve several responsible parties, such as two drivers, a trucking company, an employer, or a public agency responsible for a dangerous road. California’s Proposition 51, codified at Civil Code section 1431.2, makes each defendant’s liability for non-economic damages (such as pain, suffering, and loss of companionship) “several only,” meaning each defendant pays only its own percentage of those damages. Under that same framework, defendants can remain jointly responsible for economic damages such as medical bills and lost earnings.
This means identifying every responsible party, and every insurance policy, can make a major difference. If a city, county, or Caltrans may share the blame, remember that a government claim usually must be filed within six months. See our guide to the 6-month government claim deadline.
Are There Situations Where Fault Limits Damages More Severely?
Yes. California’s Proposition 213, codified at Civil Code section 3333.4, generally bars an injured person from recovering non-economic damages (pain, suffering, disfigurement, and similar losses) from a motor vehicle accident if they were convicted of driving under the influence in that crash, or if they were an uninsured owner or driver of a vehicle involved. Economic damages are not barred, and there are exceptions; for example, an uninsured vehicle owner hit by a driver convicted of DUI is not barred.
In Horwich, the California Supreme Court held that this rule did not prevent the parents of an uninsured driver who was killed from recovering wrongful death damages for the loss of her care, comfort, and society.
What Should You Do If Someone Says You Were Partly at Fault?
- Do not accept the adjuster’s fault percentage. It is a negotiating position, not a legal finding.
- Be careful with recorded statements. You generally are not required to give one to the other driver’s insurer.
- Preserve evidence quickly. Business and traffic cameras, vehicle data, and phone records can be lost or overwritten.
- Get medical care and follow through. Gaps in treatment are used to argue that injuries were not caused by the crash.
- Watch the deadlines. California generally allows two years to file a personal injury or wrongful death lawsuit (Code of Civil Procedure section 335.1), and usually six months for a claim against a public agency.
- Talk to an experienced injury lawyer before signing anything. Learn more about our car accident and wrongful death practice.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I sue if I was partly at fault for a car accident in California?
Yes. California’s pure comparative negligence rule lets you recover damages reduced by your percentage of fault.
What if I was 90% at fault?
You may still recover 10% of your damages from the other at-fault party, although Proposition 213 can limit non-economic damages in certain DUI and uninsured-driver situations.
Who decides my percentage of fault?
In settlement, it is negotiated. At trial, the jury decides, and the defense must prove your negligence was a substantial factor in causing your harm.
Can a family still bring a wrongful death claim if their loved one was partly to blame?
Yes. The recovery may be reduced by the decedent’s share of fault, but the claim is not automatically barred.
Does admitting fault at the scene ruin my case?
Not necessarily. Statements are evidence, but fault is determined from all of the evidence, including video, witnesses, and physical evidence.
Contact Walch Law for a Free Consultation
For more than 50 years, the Law Offices of Gary K. Walch, A Law Corporation, has represented seriously injured people and the families of wrongful death victims throughout Southern California, from our offices in Calabasas and Beverly Hills. If an insurance company is blaming you or your loved one for a serious crash, we can review the evidence and explain your options before you accept a reduced offer.
Call us today for a free consultation at 866-INJURY-2 (866-465-8792), or tell us about your case online.
This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and the examples above are illustrations only, not predictions of any result.
California Personal Injury Lawyers Blog











